| Season | OPPOSITION | VENUE | ATTS | ONE | TWO | THREE | FOUR | FIVE | SIX | SEVEN | EIGHT | NINE | TEN | ELEVEN | SUBS | ||||||||||
| 1871/72 | Wanderers | 1 | Oval | 2,000 | Welch | Bowen | AC Thompson | E Lubbock | Crake | Wollaston | Alcock | Hooman | Betts 1 | RWS Vidal | Bonsor | ||||||||||
| Royal Engineers | 0 | Merriman | Mandarin | Addison | Cresswell | Mitchell | Renny-Tailyour | Rich | Goodwyn | Muirhead | Cotter | Bogie | |||||||||||||
| 1872/73 | Wanderers | 2 | Lillie Bridge | 3,000 | Welch | Howell | Bowen | CM Thompson | Kinnaird 1 | Wollaston 1 | Sturgis | Stewart | Kenyon-Slaney | Kingsford | Bonsor | ||||||||||
| Oxford University | 0 | Leach | Mackarness | Birley | Kirke-Smith | Ottaway | Longman | FBC Maddison | Dixon | WB Paton | RWS Vidal | Sumner | |||||||||||||
| 1873/74 | Oxford University | 2 | Oval | 2,000 | Nepean | Mackarness 1 | Birley | Green | RWS Vidal | Ottaway | Benson | FJ Patton 1 | Rawson | FBC Maddison | Johnson | ||||||||||
| Royal Engineers | 0 | Merriman | Mandarin | Addison | Onslow | Digby | Oliver | Renny-Tailyour | Rawson | Blackburn | Wood | von Donop | |||||||||||||
| 1874/75 | Royal Engineers | 1 | Oval | 3,000 | Merriman | Sim | Onslow | Ruck | von Donop | Wood | Rawson | Stafford | Renny-Tailyour 1 | Mein | Wingfield-Stratford | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 1 | (a.e.t.) | Farmer | Wilson | AC Thompson | E Lubbock | Benson | Kenyon-Slaney | FJ Patton | Bonsor 1 | Ottaway | Kinnaird | Stronge | ||||||||||||
| Replay | Royal Engineers | 2 | Oval | 3,000 | Merriman | Sim | Onslow | Ruck | von Donop | Wood | Rawson | Stafford 1 | Renny-Tailyour 1 | Mein | Wingfield-Stratford | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 0 | Drummond-Moray | Farrer | E Lubbock | Wilson | Hammond | A Lubbock | FJ Patton | Farmer | Bonsor | Kinnaird | Stronge | |||||||||||||
| 1875/76 | Wanderers | 1 | Oval | 3,500 | Greig | Stratford | Lindsay | FBC Maddison | Birley | Wollaston | GHH Heron | F Heron | Edwards 1 | Kenrick | Hughes | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 1 | Hogg | Wellson | AC Thompson | E Lyttleton | A Lyttleton | Kinnaird | Kenyon-Slaney | CM Thompson | Bonsor 1 | Sturgis | Alleyne | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Wanderers | 3 | Oval | 1,500 | Greig | Stratford | Lindsay | FBC Maddison | Birley | Wollaston 1 | GHH Heron | F Heron | Edwards | Kenrick | Hughes 2 | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 0 | Hogg | E Lubbock | Farrer | E Lyttleton | A Lyttleton | Kinnaird | Kenyon-Slaney | Bonsor | Sturgis | Alleyne | Stronge | |||||||||||||
| 1876/77 | Wanderers | 2 | Oval | 3,000 | Kinnaird | Stratford | Lindsay 1 | Birley | Green | Hughes | Wollaston | GHH Heron | Wace | Kenrick 1 | Denton | ||||||||||
| Oxford University | 1 | (a.e.t.) | Allington | Waddington | Dunell | Otter | Rawson | Savory | Parry | Bain | Todd | Fernandez | Hills | ||||||||||||
| 1877/78 | Wanderers | 3 | Oval | 4,500 | Kirkpatrick | Stratford | Lindsay | Kinnaird 1 | Green | Wollaston | GHH Heron | Wylie | Wace | Denton | Kenrick 2 | ||||||||||
| Royal Engineers | 1 | Friend | Cowan | Morris | Mayne | Heath | Lindsay | Barnet | Hedley | Haynes | Bond | Ruck | |||||||||||||
| 1878/79 | Old Etonians | 1 | Oval | 5,000 | Hawtrey | Bury | Christian | Kinnaird | E Lubbock | Clerke 1 | Pares | Goodhart | Whitfield | Chevallier | Leaufoy | ||||||||||
| Clapham Rovers | 0 | Birkett | Ogilvie | E Field | Bailey | Prinsep | Rawson | Stanley | Scott | Bevington | Growse | Keith-Falconer | |||||||||||||
| 1879/80 | Clapham Rovers | 1 | Oval | 6,000 | Birkett | Ogilvie | E Field | Weston | Bailey | Stanley | Brougham | Sparks | Barry | Lloyd-Jones 1 | Ram | ||||||||||
| Oxford University | 0 | Parr | Wilson | King | Phllips | Rogers | Childs | Crowdy | Eyre | J Lubbock | Hill | Heygate | |||||||||||||
| 1880/81 | Old Carthusians | 3 | Oval | 4,500 | Gillett | Colvin | Norris | Prinsep | Vincent | Todd 1 | Parry 1 | Wynyard 1 | Page | Richards(G) | Hensell | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 0 | Rawlinson | French | Foley | Kinnaird | Farrer | Chevallier | Anderson | Goodhart | Macaulay | Whitfield | Novelli | |||||||||||||
| 1881/82 | Old Etonians | 1 | Oval | 6,500 | Rawlinson | French | de Paravicini | Kinnaird | Foley | Novelli | Dunn | Macaulay 1 | Goodhart | Chevallier | Anderson | ||||||||||
| Blackburn Rovers | 0 | Howarth | Suter | McIntyre | Sharples | F Hargreaves | Duckworth | Douglas | Brown | Strachan | Avery | J Hargreaves | |||||||||||||
| 1882/83 | Blackburn Olympic | 2 | Oval | 8,000 | Hacking | Warburton | Ward | Astley | Hunter | Gibson | Dewhurst | Matthews 1 | Yates | Crossley 1 | Wilson | ||||||||||
| Old Etonians | 1 | (a.e.t.) | Rawlinson | de Paravicini | French | Kinnaird | Foley | Anderson | Chevallier | Macaulay | Goodhart | Dunn | Bainbridge | ||||||||||||
| 1883/84 | Blackburn Rovers | 2 | Oval | 12,000 | Arthur | Beverley | Suter | McIntyre | J Hargreaves | Forrest 1 | Lofthouse | Douglas | Sowerbutts 1 | Inglis | Brown 1 | ||||||||||
| Queens Park | 1 | Gillespie | Arnott | Macdonald | Campbell | Gow | Anderson | Watt | Smith | Harrower | Allan | Christie | |||||||||||||
| 1884/85 | Blackburn Rovers | 2 | Oval | 12,500 | Arthur | Turner | Suter | Haworth | McIntyre | Forrest 1 | Lofthouse | Douglas | Brown 1 | Fecitt | Sowerbutts | ||||||||||
| Queens Park | 0 | Gillespie | Arnott | MacLeod | Campbell | MacDonald | Hamilton | McWhannel | Anderson | Sellar | Gray | Allan | |||||||||||||
| 1885/86 | Blackburn Rovers | 0 | Oval | 15,000 | Arthur | Turner | Suter | Heyes | McIntyre | Forrest | Strachan | Douglas | Brown | Fecitt | Sowerbutts | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | Roberts | H Green | Bell | Horton | Perry | Timmins | Woodhall | Green | Bayliss | Loach | Bell | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Blackburn Rovers | 2 | Derby | 12,000 | Arthur | Turner | Suter | Douglas | McIntyre | Forrest | Walton | Strachan | Brown 1 | Fecitt | Sowerbutts 1 | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | Roberts | H Green | Bell | Horton | Perry | Timmins | Woodhall | Green | Bayliss | Loach | Bell | |||||||||||||
| 1886/87 | Aston Villa | 2 | Oval | 15,500 | Warner | Coulton | Simmonds | Yates | Dawson | Burton | Brown | Hunter 1 | Vaughton | Hodgetts 1 | Davis | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | Roberts | H Green | Aldridge | Horton | Perry | Timmins | Woodhall | T Green | Bayliss | Paddock | Pearson | |||||||||||||
| 1887/88 | West Bromwich Alb. | 2 | Oval | 19,000 | Roberts | H Green | Aldridge | Horton | Perry | Timmins | Bassett | Woodhall 1 | Bayliss 1 | Pearson | Wilson | ||||||||||
| Preston North End | 1 | Mills-Roberts | Howarth | NJ Ross | Holmes | Russell | Graham | Gordon | JD Ross | Goodall | Dewhurst 1 | Drummond | |||||||||||||
| 1888/89 | Preston North End | 3 | Oval | 22,000 | Mills-Roberts | Howarth | Holmes | Drummond | Russell | Graham | Gordon | JD Ross 1 | Goodall | Dewhurst 1 | Thomson 1 | ||||||||||
| Wolverhampton W. | 0 | Baynton | Baugh | Mason | Fletcher | Allen | Lowder | T Hunter | Wykes | Brodie | Wood | Knight | |||||||||||||
| 1889/90 | Blackburn Rovers | 6 | Oval | 20,000 | Horne | Jas Southworth | Forbes | Barton | Dewar | Forrest | Lofthouse 1 | Campbell | Jo Southworth 1 | Walton 1 | Townley 3 | ||||||||||
| Sheffield Wednesday | 1 | Smith | Morley | Brayshaw | Waller | Betts | Dungworth | Ingram | Woolhouse | Mumford | Cawley | Bennett 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1890/91 | Blackburn Rovers | 3 | Oval | 23,000 | Pennington | Brandon | Forbes | Barton | Dewar 1 | Forrest | Lofthouse | Walton | Jo Southworth 1 | Hall | Townley 1 | ||||||||||
| Notts County | 1 | Thraves | Ferguson | Hendry | Osborne | Calderhead | A Shelton | McGregor | McInnes | James Oswald | Locker | Daft | |||||||||||||
| 1891/92 | West Bromwich Alb. | 3 | Oval | 32,810 | Reader | Nicholson | McCulloch | Reynolds 1 | Perry | Groves | Bassett | McLeod | Nicholls 1 | Pearson | Geddes 1 | ||||||||||
| Aston Villa | 0 | Warner | Cox | Evans | H Devey | Cowan | Baird | Athersmith | Dickson | J Devey | Campbell | Hodgetts | |||||||||||||
| 1892/93 | Wolverhampton W. | 1 | Fallowfield | 45,067 | Rose | Baugh | Swift | Malpass | Allen 1 | Kinsey | Topham | Wykes | Butcher | Griffin | Wood | ||||||||||
| Everton | 0 | Williams | Kelso | Howarth | Boyle | Holt | Stewart | Latta | Gordon | Maxwell | Chadwick | Milward | |||||||||||||
| 1893/94 | Notts County | 4 | Goodison | 37,000 | Toone | Harper | Hendrey | Bramley | Calderhead | A Shelton | Watson 1 | Donnelly | Logan 3 | Bruce | Daft | ||||||||||
| Bolton Wanderers | 1 | Sutcliffe | Somerville | Jones | Gardiner | Paton | Hughes | Tannahill | Wilson | Cassidy 1 | Bentley | Dickenson | |||||||||||||
| 1894/95 | Aston Villa | 1 | Crystal P | 42,562 | Wilkes | Spencer | Welford | Reynolds | Cowan | Russell | Athersmith | Chatt 1 | J Devey 1 | Hodgetts | Smith | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | Reader | Williams | Horton | Perry | Higgins | Taggart | Bassett | McLeod | Richards | Hutchinson | Banks | |||||||||||||
| 1895/96 | Sheffield Wednesday | 2 | Crystal P | 48,836 | Massey | Earp | Langley | Brandon | Crawshaw | Petrie | Brash | Brady | Bell | Davis | Spiksley 2 | ||||||||||
| Wolverhampton W. | 1 | Tennant | Baugh | Dunn | Owen | Malpass | Griffiths | Tanks | Henderson | Beats | Wood | Black 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1896/97 | Aston Villa | 3 | Crystal P | 65,891 | Whitehouse | Spencer | Evans | Reynolds | James Cowan | Crabtree 1 | Athersmith | J Devey | Campbell 1 | Wheldon 1 | John Cowan | ||||||||||
| Everton | 2 | Menham | Meehan | Storrier | Boyle 1 | Holt | Stewart | Taylor | Bell 1 | Hartley | Chadwick | Milward | |||||||||||||
| 1897/98 | Nottingham Forest | 3 | Crystal P | 62,017 | Allsop | Ritchie | Scott | Forman | McPherson 1 | Wragg | McInnes | Richards | Benbow | Capes 2 | Spouncer | ||||||||||
| Derby County | 1 | Fryer | Methven | Leiper | Cox | A Goodall | Turner | J Goodall | Bloomer 1 | Boag | Stevenson | McQueen | |||||||||||||
| 1898/99 | Sheffield United | 4 | Crystal P | 73,833 | Foulke | Thickett | Boyle | Johnson | Morren | Needham | Bennett 1 | Beers 1 | Hedley | Almond 1 | Priest 1 | ||||||||||
| Derby County | 1 | Fryer | Methven | Staley | Cox | Paterson | May | Arkesden | Bloomer | Boag 1 | MacDonald | Allen | |||||||||||||
| 1899/00 | Bury | 4 | Crystal P | 68,945 | Thompson | Darroch | Davidson | Pray | Leeimg | Ross | Richards | Wood 1 | McLuckie 2 | Sagar | Plant 1 | ||||||||||
| Southampton | 0 | Robinson | Meehan | Durber | Meston | Chadwick | Petrie | Turner | Yates | Farrell | Wood | Milward | |||||||||||||
| 1900/01 | Tottenham Hotspur | 2 | Crystal P | 114,815 | Clawley | Erentz | Tait | Morris | Hughes | Jones | Smith | Cameron | Brown 2 | Copeland | Kirwan | ||||||||||
| Sheffield United | 2 | Foulke | Thickett | Boyle | Johnson | Morren | Needham | Bennett 1 | Field | Hedley | Priest 1 | Lipsham | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Tottenham Hotspur | 3 | Burnden Park | 20,470 | Clawley | Erentz | Tait | Morris | Hughes | Jones | Smith 1 | Cameron | Brown 1 | Copeland 1 | Kirwan | ||||||||||
| Sheffield United | 1 | Foulke | Thickett | Boyle | Johnson | Morren | Needham | Bennett | Field | Hedley | Priest 1 | Lipsham | |||||||||||||
| 1901/02 | Sheffield United | 1 | Crystal P | 76,914 | Foulke | Thickett | Boyle | Johnson | Wilkinson | Needham | Bennett | Common 1 | Hedley | Priest | Lipsham | ||||||||||
| Southampton | 1 | Robinson | CB Fry | Molyneux | Meston | Bowman | Lee | A Turner | Wood 1 | Brown | Chadwick | J Turner | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Sheffield United | 2 | Crystal P | 33,068 | Foulke | Thickett | Boyle | Johnson | Wilkinson | Needham | Barnes 1 | Common | Hedley 1 | Priest | Lipsham | ||||||||||
| Southampton | 1 | Robinson(J) | CB Fry | Molyneux | Meston | Bowman | Lee | A Turner | Wood | Brown 1 | Chadwick | J Turner | |||||||||||||
| 1902/03 | Bury | 6 | Crystal P | 63,102 | Monteith | Lindsey | McEwen | Johnstone | Thorpe | Ross 1 | Richards | Wood 1 | Sagar 1 | Leeming 2 | Plant 1 | ||||||||||
| Derby County | 0 | Fryer | Methven | Morris | Warren | A Goodall | May | Warrington | York | Boag | Richards | Davis | |||||||||||||
| 1903/04 | Manchester City | 1 | Crystal P | 61,374 | Hillman | McMahon | Burgess | Frost | Hynds | Ashworth | Meredith 1 | Livingstone | Gillespie | A Turnbull | Booth | ||||||||||
| Bolton Wanderers | 0 | Davies | Brown | Struthers | Clifford | Greenhalgh | Freebairn | Stokes | Marsh | Yenson | White | Taylor | |||||||||||||
| 1904/05 | Aston Villa | 2 | Crystal P | 101,117 | George | Spencer | Miles | Pearson | Leake | Windmill | Brawn | Garraty | Hampton 2 | Bache | Hall | ||||||||||
| Newcastle United | 0 | Lawrence | McCombie | Carr | Gardner | Aitken | McWilliam | Rutherford | Howie | Appleyard | Veitch | Gosnell | |||||||||||||
| 1905/06 | Everton | 1 | Crystal P | 75,609 | Scott | W Balmer | Crelley | Makepeace | Taylor | Abbott | Sharp | Bolton | Young 1 | Settle | Hardman | ||||||||||
| Newcastle United | 0 | Lawrence | McCombie | Carr | Gardner | Aitken | McWilliam | Rutherford | Howie | Veitch | Orr | Gosnell | |||||||||||||
| 1906/07 | Sheffield Wednesday | 2 | Crystal P | 84,584 | Lyall | Layton | Burton | Brittleton | Crawshaw | Bartlett | Chapman | Bradshaw | Wilson | Stewart 1 | Simpson 1 | ||||||||||
| Everton | 1 | Scott | W Balmer | R Balmer | Makepeace | Taylor | Abbott | Sharp 1 | Bolton | Young | Settle | Hardman | |||||||||||||
| 1907/08 | Wolverhampton W. | 3 | Crystal P | 74,697 | Lunn | Jones | Collins | Hunt 1 | Wooldridge | Bishop | Harrison 1 | Shelton | Hedley 1 | Radford | Pedley | ||||||||||
| Newcastle United | 1 | Lawrence | McCracken | Pudan | Gardner | Veitch | McWilliam | Rutherford | Howie 1 | Appleyard | Speedie | Wilson | |||||||||||||
| 1908/09 | Manchester United | 1 | Crystal P | 71,401 | Moger | Stacey | Hayes | Duckworth | Roberts | Bell | Meredith | Halse | J Turnbull | A Turnbull 1 | Wall | ||||||||||
| Bristol City | 0 | Clay | Annan | Cottle | Hanlin | Wedlock | Spear | Staniforth | Hardy | Gilligan | Burton | Hilton | |||||||||||||
| 1909/10 | Newcastle United | 1 | Crystal P | 76,980 | Lawrence | McCracken | Whitson | Veitch | Low | McWilliam | Rutherford 1 | Howie | Shepherd | Higgins | Wilson | ||||||||||
| Barnsley | 1 | Mearns | Downs | Ness | Glendinning | Boyle | Utley | Tufnell 1 | Lillycrop | Gadsby | Forman | Bartrop | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Newcastle United | 2 | Goodison | 55,364 | Lawrence | McCracken | Carr | Veitch | Low | McWilliam | Rutherford | Howie | Shepherd 2(1p) | Higgins | Wilson | ||||||||||
| Barnsley | 0 | Mearns | Downs | Ness | Glendinning | Boyle | Utley | Tufnell | Lillycrop | Gadsby | Forman | Bartrop | |||||||||||||
| 1910/11 | Bradford City | 0 | Crystal P | 69,098 | Mellors | Campbell | Taylor | Robinson | Gildea | McDonald | Logan | Speirs | O'Rourke | Devine | Thompson | ||||||||||
| Newcastle United | 0 | Lawrence | McCracken | Whitson | Veitch | Low | Willis | Rutherford | Stewart | Jobey | Higgins | Wilson | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Bradford City | 1 | Old Trafford | 58,000 | Mellors | Campbell | Taylor | Robinson | Torrance | McDonald | Logan | Speirs 1 | O'Rourke | Devine | Thompson | ||||||||||
| Newcastle United | 0 | Lawrence | McCracken | Whitson | Veitch | Low | Willis | Rutherford | Stewart | Jobey | Higgins | Wilson | |||||||||||||
| 1911/12 | Barnsley | 0 | Crystal P | 54,556 | Copper | Downs | Taylor | Glendinning | Bratley | Utley | Bartrop | Tufnell | Lillycrop | Travers | Moore | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | Pearson | Cook | Pennington | Baddeley | Buck | McNeal | Jephcott | Wright | Pailor | Bowser | Shearman | |||||||||||||
| Replay | Barnsley | 1 | Bramall Lane | 38,555 | Copper | Downs | Taylor | Glendinning | Bratley | Utley | Bartrop | Tufnell 1 | Lillycrop | Travers | Moore | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 0 | (a.e.t.) | Pearson | Cook | Pennington | Baddeley | Buck | McNeal | Jephcott | Wright | Pailor | Bowser | Shearman | ||||||||||||
| 1912/13 | Aston Villa | 1 | Crystal P | 121,919 | Hardy | Lyons | Weston | Barber 1 | Harrop | Leach | Wallace | Halse | Hampton | Stephenson | Bache | ||||||||||
| Sunderland | 0 | Butler | Gladwin | Ness | Cuggy | Thomson | Low | Mordue | Buchan | Richardson | Holley | Martin | |||||||||||||
| 1913/14 | Burnley | 1 | Crystal P | 72,778 | Sewell | Bamford | Taylor | Halley | Boyle | Watson | Nesbitt | Lindley | Freeman 1 | Hodgson | Mosscrop | ||||||||||
| Liverpool | 0 | Campbell | Longworth | Pursell | Fairfoul | Ferguson | McKinlay | Sheldon | Metcalf | Miller | Nicholl | Lacey | |||||||||||||
| 1914/15 | Sheffield United | 3 | Old Trafford | 49,557 | Gough | Cook | English | Sturgess | Brailsford | Utley | Simmons 1 | Fazackerly 1 | Kitchen 1 | Masterman | Evans | ||||||||||
| Chelsea | 0 | Molyneux | Bettridge | Harrow | Taylor | Logan | Walker | Ford | Halse | Thomson | Croal | McNeil | |||||||||||||
| 1919/20 | Aston Villa | 1 | Stamford Bridge | 50,018 | Hardy | Smart | Weston | Ducat | Barson | Moss | Wallace | Kirton 1 | Walker | Stephenson | Dorrell | ||||||||||
| Huddersfield Town | 0 | (a.e.t.) | Mutch | Wood | Bullock | Slade | Wilson | Watson | Richardson | Mann | Taylor | Swann | Islip | ||||||||||||
| 1920/21 | Tottenham Hotspur | 1 | Stamford Bridge | 72,805 | Hunter | Clay | McDonald | Smith | Walters | Grimsdell | Banks | Seed | Cantrell | Bliss | Dimmock 1 | ||||||||||
| Wolverhampton W. | 0 | George | Woodward | Marshall | Gregory | Hodnett | Riley | Lea | Burrill | Edmonds | Potts | Brooks | |||||||||||||
| 1921/22 | Huddersfield Town | 1 | Stamford Bridge | 53,000 | Mutch | Wood | Wadsworth | Slade | Wilson | Watson | Richardson | Mann | Islip | Stephenson | WH Smith 1(p) | ||||||||||
| Preston North End | 0 | JF Mitchell | Hamilton | Doolan | Duxberry | McCall | Williamson | Rawlings | Jefferis | Roberts | Woodhouse | Quinn | |||||||||||||
| 1922/23 | Bolton Wanderers | 2 | Wembley | 126,047 | Pym | Haworth | Finney | Nuttall | Seddon | Jennings | Butler | Jack 1 | JR Smith 1 | Joe Smith | Vizard | ||||||||||
| West Ham United | 0 | Hufton | Henderson | Young | Bishop | Kay | Tresadern | Richards | Brown | Watson | Moore | Ruffell | |||||||||||||
| 1923/24 | Newcastle United | 2 | Wembley | 91,645 | Bradley | Hampson | Hudspeth | Mooney | Spencer | Gibson | Low | Cowan | Harris 1 | McDonald | Seymour 1 | ||||||||||
| Aston Villa | 0 | Jackson | Smart | Mort | Moss | Milne | Blackburn | York | Kirton | Capewell | Walker | Dorrell | |||||||||||||
| 1924/25 | Sheffield United | 1 | Wembley | 91,763 | Sutcliffe | Cook | Mitton | Pantling | King | Green | Mercer | Boyle | Johnson | Gillespie | Tunstall 1 | ||||||||||
| Cardiff City | 0 | Farquarson | Nelson | Blair | Wake | Keenor | Hardy | W Davies | Gill | Nicholson | Beadles | D Evans | |||||||||||||
| 1925/26 | Bolton Wanderers | 1 | Wembley | 91,547 | Pym | Haworth | Greenhalgh | Nuttall | Seddon | Jennings | Butler | Jack 1 | JR Smith | Joe Smith | Vizard | ||||||||||
| Manchester City | 0 | Goodchild | Cookson | McCloy | Pringle | Cowan | McMullan | Austin | Browell | Roberts | Johnson | Hicks | |||||||||||||
| 1926/27 | Cardiff City | 1 | Wembley | 91,206 | Farquarson | Nelson | Watson | Keenor | Sloan | Hardy | Curtis | Irving | Ferguson 1 | L Davies | McLachlan | ||||||||||
| Arsenal | 0 | Lewis | Parker | Kennedy | Baker | Butler | John | Hulme | Buchan | Brain | Blyth | Hoar | |||||||||||||
| 1927/28 | Blackburn Rovers | 3 | Wembley | 92,041 | Crawford | Hutton | Jones | Healless | Rankin | Campbell | Thornewell | Puddefoot | Roscamp 2 | McLean 1 | Rigby | ||||||||||
| Huddersfield Town | 1 | Mercer | Goodall | Barkas | Redfern | Wilson | Steele | A Jackson 1 | Kelly | Brown | Stephenson | WH Smith | |||||||||||||
| 1928/29 | Bolton Wanderers | 2 | Wembley | 92,576 | Pym | Haworth | Finney | Kean | Seddon | Nuttall | Butler 1 | McClelland | Blackmore 1 | Gibson | W Cook | ||||||||||
| Portsmouth | 0 | Gilfillan | Mackie | Bell | Nichol | McIlwaine | Thackeray | Forward | Smith | Weddle | Watson | F Cook | |||||||||||||
| 1929/30 | Arsenal | 2 | Wembley | 92,486 | Preedy | Parker | Hapgood | Baker | Seddon | John | Hulme | Jack | Lambert 1 | James 1 | Bastin | ||||||||||
| Huddersfield Town | 0 | Turner | Goodall | Spence | Naylor | Wilson | Campbell | Jackson | Kelly | Davies | Raw | Smith | |||||||||||||
| 1930/31 | West Bromwich Alb. | 2 | Wembley | 92,406 | Pearson | Shaw | Trentham | Magee | W Richardson | Edwards | Glidden | Carter | WG Richardson 2 | Sandford | Wood | ||||||||||
| Birmingham | 1 | Hibbs | Liddell | Barkas | Cringan | Morrall | Leslie | Briggs | Crosbie | Bradford 1 | Gregg | Curtis | |||||||||||||
| 1931/32 | Newcastle United | 2 | Wembley | 92,298 | McInroy | Nelson | Fairhurst | McKenzie | Davidson | Weaver | Boyd | JR Richardson | Allen 2 | McMenemy | Lang | ||||||||||
| Arsenal | 1 | Moss | Parker | Hapgood | Jones | Roberts | Male | Hulme | Jack | Lambert | Bastin | John 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1932/33 | Everton | 3 | Wembley | 92,900 | Sagar | Cook | Cresswell | Britton | White | Thomson | Geldard | Dunn 1 | Dean 1 | Johnson | Stein 1 | ||||||||||
| Manchester City | 0 | Langford | Cann | Dale | Busby | Cowan | Bray | Toseland | Marshall | Herd | McMullan | Brook | |||||||||||||
| 1933/34 | Manchester City | 2 | Wembley | 93,258 | Swift | Barnett | Dale | Busby | Cowan | Bray | Toseland | Marshall | Tilson 2 | Herd | Brook | ||||||||||
| Portsmouth | 1 | Gilfillan | Mackie | W Smith | Nichol | Allen | Thackeray | Worrall | J Smith | Weddle | Easson | Rutherford 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1934/35 | Sheffield Wednesday | 4 | Wembley | 93,204 | Brown | Nibloe | Catlin | Sharp | Millership | Burrows | Hooper 1 | Surtees | Palethorpe 1 | Starling | Rimmer 2 | ||||||||||
| West Bromwich Alb. | 2 | Pearson | Shaw | Trentham | Murphy | W Richardson | Edwards | Glidden | Carter | WG Richardson | Sandford 1 | Boyes 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1935/36 | Arsenal | 1 | Wembley | 93,384 | Wilson | Male | Hapgood | Crayston | Roberts | Copping | Hulme | Bowden | Drake 1 | James | Bastin | ||||||||||
| Sheffield United | 0 | Smith | Hooper | Wilkinson | Jackson | Johnson | McPherson | Barton | Barclay | Dodds | Pickering | Williams | |||||||||||||
| 1936/37 | Sunderland | 3 | Wembley | 93,495 | Mapson | Gorman | Hall | Thomson | Johnston | McNab | Duns | Carter 1 | Gurney 1 | Gallacher | Burbanks 1 | ||||||||||
| Preston North End | 1 | Burns | Gallimore | A Beattie | Shankly | Tremelling | Milne | Dougal | Beresford | F O'Donnell 1 | Fagan | H O'Donnell | |||||||||||||
| 1937/38 | Preston North End | 1 | Wembley | 93,357 | Holdcroft | Gallimore | A Beattie | Shankly | Smith | Batey | Watmough | Mutch 1(p) | Maxwell | R Beattie | H O'Donnell | ||||||||||
| Huddersfield Town | 0 | (a.e.t.) | Hesford | Craig | Mountford | Willingham | Young | Boot | Hulme | Isaac | MacFadyen | Barclay | Beasley | ||||||||||||
| 1938/39 | Portsmouth | 4 | Wembley | 99,370 | Walker | Morgan | Rochford | Guthrie | Rowe | Wharton | Worrall | McAlinden | Anderson 1 | Barlow 2 | Parker 1 | ||||||||||
| Wolverhampton W. | 1 | Scott | Morris | Taylor | Galley | Cullis | Gardiner | Burton | McIntosh | Westcott | Dorsett 1 | Maguire | |||||||||||||
| 1945/46 | Derby County | 4 | Wembley | 98,215 | Woodley | Nicholas | Howe | Bullions | Leuty | Musson | Harrison | Carter | Stamps 2 | Doherty 1 | Duncan | ||||||||||
| Charlton Athletic | 1 | (a.e.t.) | Bartram | Phipps | Shreeve | R Turner | Oakes | Johnson | Fell | Brown | AATurner | Welsh | Duffy | ||||||||||||
| 1946/47 | Charlton Athletic | 1 | Wembley | 98,215 | Bartram | Croker | Shreeve | Johnson | Phipps | Whittaker | Hurst | Dawson | Robinson | Welsh | Duffy 1 | ||||||||||
| Burnley | 0 | (a.e.t.) | Strong | Woodruff | Mather | Attwell | Brown | Bray | Chew | Morris | Harrison | Potts | Kippax | ||||||||||||
| 1947/48 | Manchester United | 4 | Wembley | 99,000 | Crompton | Carey | Aston | Anderson 1 | Chilton | Cockburn | Delaney | Morris | Rowley 2 | Pearson 1 | Mitten | ||||||||||
| Blackpool | 2 | Robinson | Shimwell 1(p) | Crosland | Johnston | Hayward | Kelly | Matthews | Munro | Mortenson 1 | Dick | Rickett | |||||||||||||
| 1948/49 | Wolverhampton W. | 3 | Wembley | 98,920 | Williams | Pritchard | Springthorpe | Crook | Shorthouse | Wright | Hancocks | Smyth 1 | Pye 2 | Dunn | Mullen | ||||||||||
| Leicester City | 1 | Bradley | Jelly | Scott | W Harrison | Plummer | King | Griffiths 1 | Lee | J Harrison | Chisholm | Adam | |||||||||||||
| 1949/50 | Arsenal | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Swindin | Scott | Barnes | Forbes | L Compton | Mercer | Cox | Logie | Goring | Lewis 2 | D Compton | ||||||||||
| Liverpool | 0 | Sidlow | Lambert | Spicer | Taylor | Jones | Hughes | Payne | Baron | Stubbins | Fagan | Liddell | |||||||||||||
| 1950/51 | Newcastle United | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Fairbrother | Cowell | Corbett | Harvey | Brennan | Crowe | Walker | Taylor | Milburn 2 | Robledo | Mitchell | ||||||||||
| Blackpool | 0 | Farm | Shimwell | Garrett | Johnston | Hayward | Kelly | Matthews | Mudie | Mortensen | Slater | Perry | |||||||||||||
| 1951/52 | Newcastle United | 1 | Wembley | 100,000 | Simpson | Cowell | McMichael | Harvey | Brennan | E Robledo | Walker | Foulkes | Milburn | G Robledo 1 | Mitchell | ||||||||||
| Arsenal | 0 | Swindin | Barnes | Smith | Forbes | Daniel | Mercer | Cox | Logie | Holton | Lishman | Roper | |||||||||||||
| 1952/53 | Blackpool | 4 | Wembley | 100,000 | Farm | Shimwell | Garrett | Fenton | Johnston | Robinson | Matthews | Taylor | Mortensen 3 | Mudie | Perry 1 | ||||||||||
| Bolton Wanderers | 3 | Hanson | Ball | Banks | Wheeler | Barrass | Bell 1 | Holden | Moir 1 | Lofthouse 1 | Hassall | Langton | |||||||||||||
| 1953/54 | West Bromwich Alb. | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Sanders | Kennedy | Millard | Dudley | Dugdale | Barlow | Griffin 1 | Ryan | Allen 2 (1p) | Nicholls | Lee | ||||||||||
| Preston North End | 2 | Thompson | Cunningham | Walton | Docherty | Marston | Forbes | Finney | Foster | Wayman 1 | Baxter | Morrison 1 | |||||||||||||
| 1954/55 | Newcastle United | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Simpson | Cowell | Batty | Scoular | Stokoe | Casey | White | Milburn 1 | Keeble | Hannah 1 | Mitchell 1 | ||||||||||
| Manchester City | 1 | Trautmann | Meadows | Little | Barnes | Ewing | Paul | Spurdle | Hayes | Revie | Johnstone 1 | Fagan | |||||||||||||
| 1955/56 | Manchester City | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Trautmann | Leivers | Little | Barnes | Ewing | Paul | Johnstone 1 | Hayes 1 | Revie | Dyson 1 | Clarke | ||||||||||
| Birmingham City | 1 | Merrick | Hall | Green | Newman | Smith | Boyd | Astall | Kinsey 1 | Brown | Murphy | Govan | |||||||||||||
| 1956/57 | Aston Villa | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Sims | Lynn | Aldis | Crowther | Dugdale | Saward | Smith | Sewell | Myerscough | Dixon | McParland 2 | ||||||||||
| Manchester United | 1 | Wood | Foulkes | Byrne | Colman | J Blanchflower | Edwards | Berry | Whelan | Taylor 1 | Charlton | Pegg | |||||||||||||
| 1957/58 | Bolton Wanderers | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Hopkinson | Hartle | Banks | Hennin | Higgins | Edwards | Birch | Stevens | Lofthouse 2 | Parry | Holden | ||||||||||
| Manchester United | 0 | Gregg | Foulkes | Greaves | Goodwin | Cope | Crowther | Dawson | Taylor | Charlton | Viollet | Webster | |||||||||||||
| 1958/59 | Nottingham Forest | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Thomson | Whare | McDonald | Whitefoot | McKinlay(R) | Burkitt | Dwight 1 | Quigley | Wilson 1 | Gray | Imlach | ||||||||||
| Luton Town | 1 | Baynham | McNally | Hawkes | Groves | Owen | Pacey 1 | Bingham | Brown | Morton | Cummins | Gregory | |||||||||||||
| 1959/60 | Wolverhampton W. | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Finlayson | Showell | Harris | Clamp | Slater | Flowers | Deeley 2 | Stobart | Murray | Broadbent | Horne | ||||||||||
| Blackburn Rovers | 0 | Leyland | Bray | Whelan | Clayton | Woods | McGrath | Bimpson | Dobing | Dougan | Douglas | MacLeod | |||||||||||||
| 1960/61 | Tottenham Hotspur | 2 | Wembley | 100,000 | Brown | Baker | Henry | Blanchflower | Norman | Mackay | Jones | White | Smith 1 | Allen | Dyson 1 | ||||||||||
| Leicester City | 0 | Banks | Chalmers | Norman | McLintock | King | Appleton | Riley | Walsh | McIlmoyle | Keyworth | Cheesebrough | |||||||||||||
| 1961/62 | Tottenham Hotspur | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Brown | Baker | Henry | Blanchflower 1(p) | Norman | Mackay | Medwin | White | Smith 1 | Greaves 1 | Jones | ||||||||||
| Burnley | 1 | Blacklaw | Angus | Elder | Adamson | Cummings | Miller | Connelly | McIlroy | Pointer | Robson 1(p) | Harris | |||||||||||||
| 1962/63 | Manchester United | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Gaskell | Dunne | Cantwell | Crerand | Foulkes | Setters | Giles | Quixall | Herd 2 | Law 1 | Charlton | ||||||||||
| Leicester City | 1 | Banks | Sjoberg | Norman | McLintock | King | Appleton | Riley | Cross | Keyworth 1 | Gibson | Stringfellow | |||||||||||||
| 1963/64 | West Ham United | 3 | Wembley | 100,000 | Standen | Bond | Burkett | Bovington | Brown | Moore | Brabrook | Boyce 1 | Byrne | Hurst 1 | Sissons 1 | ||||||||||